Admin portal not recognizing Sendgrid API Key

Hi all - I’m trying to enable outgoing email from my app. I got a heads up from a user that the reset password email wasn’t working, and I think it’s because I haven’t enabled Sendgrid yet.

I went in and created a new API key using my sendgrid account, and I added the API key on the plug in page as the instructions said, but it’s not recognizing it in the admin portal. See screenshots below:

API key in plugins tab:

Admin portal:

Hello @toby !

Make sure that your sender email is verified in Sendgrid